Penomet Vs Bathmate: Which Of The Two Popular Pumps is Better?

Penomet and Bathmate are the leading penis pumps on the market today. If just like me you are seeking for the perfect pump that can grow your girth and give you superb erection, you are probably torn between the two. This article will help you decide which between the two is better.

Penomet and Bathmate have their own strength and advantages over one another that is why it is very difficult to decide between the two. A number of men, seeking for the best penis pumps are most of the time caught in the dilemma of choosing between these two great male enhancement devices. I’ve been there too, so I will share with you the knowledge I learned from my research regarding these two products.

What is Penomet?

bathmate vs penomet

If you want a guaranteed pump, Penomet is the brand. According to Penomet on their official website, their scientifically proven pump is the industry’s first and only certified pump. It is safe, powerful and effective in enlarging the penis.

This revolutionary penis enhancement device is a product of hard work from the experts and is backed by over two years of real-life testing making it even more reliable.

What is Bathmate?

While Penomet only offers one product with different gaiters, Bathmate offers a line of different products that you can choose from. It includes Bathmate Originals, Hydromax X-Series and Hydromax Xtreme-Series.

Bathmate Originals, from the name itself, is the first pump from Bathmate. This has been improved in Hydromax X-Series and more features for your convenience are added in the Xtreme-Series. In short, the company is aware that one size does not fit all. So, to cater the different needs of men, they bring us different pumps with the latter models more improved compared to its predecessor.

Now that you already have an overview of the two pumps, it’s great to look at their similarities and differences. Let’s examined this one by one.

Gains in Girth and Length

Both enlargement pumps are recommended for a 15-minute session but offer slightly different results. However, both are promising.

Bathmate can give you 1-3 inches gains in length and 30% in girth. However, aside from this, it can give you stronger and harder erection for a better bed performance that will surely please your partner.

Penomet offers the same results. It can grow your penis by up to 3 inches in length and 30% in girth.

In this section, the two brands have the same performance. Thus, no one is better when it comes to results.


bathmate pumps goliath hercules
Source: Official Hydromax Pump

In most instances, Penomet and Bathmate have a close resemblance but in this particular factor, Bathmate wins.

Bathmate is aware that men have different sizes. Thus, it offers different products. For men, like me, seeking for a product that fits our requirements is quite challenging. So, it is a huge point for a brand to offer different variants.

Bathmate includes Bathmate Originals (Hercules and Goliath), Hydromax X-Series (X20, X30 and X40), and Hydromax Xtreme-Series (XX20, XX30, XX40, XX50). These give you a number of options to choose from of what fits you best.

On the other hand, Penomet offers only one variant but with different gaiters. It can’t accommodate a too small or too large penis.


Bathmate is confident with their product so they offer a 2-year warranty. Aside from this, they also offer a 60-day full refund for unsatisfied and unhappy costumers.

Penomet has a more competitive warranty, though. It offers 60-Day Money Back Guarantee and 3-Year Warranty. Any customer who will get this product will surely be impressed with its warranty.


Both brands are among the most expensive pumps in the market today. However, in this factor, Bathmate has won again due to the different variants it offers.

Bathmate Originals, in particular, Hercules, is only priced at $110. The good thing about this is that this size fits most men with a small member. I, personally, started with Hercules. The different series are priced differently. The most expensive one is Xtreme X40 and X50, which are priced at $349. These pumps are for men who are already well-endowed and want to experience more gains or have plateaued on their old pump.

Meanwhile, Penomet only offers one-size pump but you can choose different gaiters available at different prices. The most expensive, Penomet Premium that includes Force 60, 65, 70, 75, and Extreme Force 80 Gaiter is available for $297. The same version of Penomet pump with only Force 70 Gaiter is up for grab for $127.


bathmate penis pump reviews

The two pumps are made of different materials but both are comfortable under water. The great thing about Bathmate Hydromax and Xtreme is that it comes with removable comfort pad.

This accessory is extra as you can use rubber itself and still feel comfortable. However, having the comfort pad is slightly easier on the skin. Penomet used to offer its own comfort pad but discontinued it after receiving negative feedback from the customers.


When it comes to cleaning these pumps, both are easy to manage. However, Penomet is more painless and effortless.

Penomet includes removable gaiters (these are replaceable so you can remove it). The package also includes cleaning foam called “Gun Oil Shine” for a more convenient cleaning. Bathmate is still easy to clean. However, the winner here is Penomet.

Pump Pressure

Source: Donna Moderna

Pressure is very important for pumps as this is behind its magic. I used different Bathmates for years but I also had my time with Penomet, it just didn’t last longer than I expected.

Bathmate and Penomet are made of different materials. Bathmate uses a slightly softer rubber while Penomet uses a tougher silicone. Rubber is stronger than silicone that is why Bathmate delivers stronger pressure than Penomet.

Penomet’s maximum pressure using the Force 80 Gaiter doesn’t compare to the performance of Bathmate Hydromax X30. All the more with Bathmate Xtreme X40. While I can recommend Penomet for beginners, it’s not something sufficient for long term use. With Bathmate Hydromax, there is always enough pressure for you even if you feel maxed out.

Meanwhile, the Bathmate Originals have a weaker gaiter similar to Penomet’s Extreme Force 80 Gaiter. Since Bathmate offers different products, this gives you the option to choose from its three different products. The originals can last you for a couple of months, the Hydromax X-series for years and the Xtreme series for more years.

Value for Money

Source: Bathmate Hydromax

There is no doubt that both offer impressive gains. However, if I have to choose one between the two, considering the pressure, comfort, versatility and quality, Bathmate excels and is a great value for money. I am very happy with the results and convenience this pump offers. It is worth every penny.

Meanwhile, I find Penomet too expensive for its quality and performance. Initially, Penomet Premium was priced at $457 but its extreme gaiters only compare to the lowest end of Bathmate products. I don’t really find Penomet worth the money. Read our comprehensive Bathmate review here.

Where to Buy Penomet?

If you’re looking to buy Penomet, you can  get it here

Conclusion – Wrapping Up!

If you are torn between Penomet and Bathmate, I recommend that you go for the latter. Due to the different lines of product that you can choose from Bathmate, you will definitely find the one that fits your budget and size.

Bathmate has the quality, comfort, versatility and results that we need to purchase a great item. In addition to this, it includes money-back guarantee and 2-year warranty. There is no reason not to choose Bathmate over another brand!